What’s Wrong With The Sinner’s Prayer by A.W. Tozer

Can you also try and imagine this scene where Jesus is leading some new “disciples” in the “sinner’s prayer”?

“Wow! There are so many that came forward for salvation tonight!” (The multitude applauds.) “Now, it’s very simple. You just repeat this little prayer after Me, and then you’re a Christian! Now it doesn’t really matter whether you fully understand the prayer…it works just the same. Now ready? Repeat after Me… Dear Jesus…Come into my heart…” and so on…

As you can see, when we try to picture Jesus Himself using our modern methods of evangelism, it seems completely foolish. I think this is a very good test for any method. “Could I see Jesus doing this?” or “Could I see Jesus preaching or teaching this?” Since the Bible tells us, “Walk in the manner that He walked” (1 John 2:6), we should always try to compare our actions and message to the Master’s.

It is obvious that there is no “set” sinner’s prayer. There are many variations, with different lengths, different wordings, different endings, etc., but the contents are usually the same. The prayer usually includes phrases like, “Dear Jesus,” “Come into my heart,” “I admit I have sinned” (at least the better ones contain this last statement – there are some who do not even like to mention sin in their “sinner’s prayer”), “Fill me with Your Spirit,” “In Jesus’ name. Amen.” Extremely harmless…nothing wrong with a prayer like that, right? Wrong! It isn’t the wording that’s important, it’s the state of the heart of the one saying it.

I believe that a true “sinner’s prayer” will gush out of anyone who is truly seeking God and is tired of being enslaved to sin. (Matt. 5:6) The very act of “leading someone in a prayer” is utterly ridiculous. You will find nothing even remotely like it in the Bible, or among the writings and biographies of those in Church history. It completely savors of crowd and peer pressure tactics, and (please forgive me) brainwashing techniques. I do not believe that Jesus wants to have his disciples “repeat after Me,” I believe He wants them to follow after Him! (Matt. 4:19, 8:22, 9:9, 16:24, 19:21; Luke 9:59; John 12:26, 21:19,22; 1 Peter 2:21; Rev. 14:4.)

As with the altar call, the practice of having someone repeat a prayer with the minister probably originated from the best of intentions. And no doubt, there are those who have “followed through,” continuing to pray and walk with God, entering into the path of righteousness through God’s infinite grace. But also, like the altar call, the so-called “sinner’s prayer” is one of those tools that make it alarmingly easy for someone to consider himself a Christian, when he has absolutely no understanding of what “counting the cost” (Luke 14:28) really means.

The greatest reason I believe that God can be grieved with the current use of such tools as the “altar call” and “sinner’s prayer” is because they can take away the conviction of the Holy Spirit prematurely, before the Spirit has time to work repentance leading to salvation. With an emotional splash that usually doesn’t last more than a few weeks, we believe we’re leading people into the Kingdom, when really we’re leading many to hell – by interfering with what the Spirit of God is trying to do in a person’s life. Do you hear? Do you understand that this constitutes “spiritual abortion“? Can’t you see the eternal consequences of jumping the gun, trying to bring to birth a baby that isn’t ready?

We are so afraid that we’ll see a “big one that got away,” that we’d rather rush someone into a shallow decision, and get the personal gratification of seeing him “go down the aisle,” than take the time to fully explain things to him, even it if takes long hours and nights of travailing prayer for his soul. We just don’t “have the time” to do things God’s way anymore. (In contrast to this, look at the amount of time and effort Jesus took to explain salvation to one mere Samaritan woman – John 4:3-42.)

But God would rather see one true convert than an ocean full of “decisions.” Oh, can’t you see what a mess we’re in? What we’ve done to the Gospel? And when those “converts” no longer want to fellowship with us, when they want to go back to their old friends and their old way of life, we have the nerve to call it “backsliding,” when we stood in the very way of them ever “front-sliding” toward the cross! Oh, it breaks my heart to think of that awesome day, when God will judge those who have “stumbled one of these little ones.” (Mark 9:42).

6 thoughts on “What’s Wrong With The Sinner’s Prayer by A.W. Tozer

  1. Lifesong October 14, 2009 / 5:19 pm

    Great post! I praise God for you!

    • Joshua Glaze March 16, 2011 / 10:34 pm

      This is great! But A.W. Tozer did not say or write this. This is the work of Keith Green which was inspired by A.W. Tozer.

  2. Pingback: Sinner's Prayer
  3. Justin September 23, 2012 / 12:36 am

    I don’t think the “sinners prayer” should be dismissed like this as it were something that is wrong. We are to open our hearts to Christ, repent of our sins, and confess with our mouths. Keith Green also says the sinners prayer has sent more men to hell then all the brothels in North America. If a person says a prayer that is “sinners prayer” material and means it with his or hers heart they do become one of God’s children. I believe Keith Green is a brother in the Lord I just think some of his messages were maybe laced with pride at times.

    • annawood September 27, 2012 / 8:14 pm

      You touch on several different issues in this. 1) Some who have prayed the Sinner’s Prayer are genuinely saved; however it wasn’t the prayer that saved them, it was God’s grace shown by drawing the sinner to Him. 2) The Sinner’s Prayer could only be part of someone’s condemnation to hell by the person falsely believing themselves to be saved by it when in fact they weren’t; however if God intended to save that person they would have been saved. Period. 3) Whether Keith Green’s lyrics were sometimes laced with pride I don’t know. I have only heard a few of Mr. Green’s songs but have liked the ones I have been able to hear. Thanks for coming by and taking the time to comment. God bless you. ~ Anna

    • Lalo October 16, 2012 / 1:32 pm

      Show me in the Bible where it says we are to “open our hearts” ????? That is non-sense. People take Romans chapter 10 and John chapter 1 in the wrong context. It is not right to twist scripture into something that it is not. The Word (Jesus Christ as stated in John 1) has the power to convict and transform. To receive Him, means to take to “heart the Word”. Without the true Gospel being preached, how can a person “receive” Jesus (Bunch of health and wealth, watered down gospel being spoken these days). How can a person be saved when all they have heard are lies, including the lie about repeating something to get your golden ticket to heaven.

Having read this, what do you have to say about it?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s